Updated November 19, 2026
At a glance: what the numbers say
- 1 gram of glycine reads as 1.17 grams of "protein" on a nitrogen test. Glycine (C2H5NO2, molecular weight 75.07) is 18.66% nitrogen. 0.1866 g nitrogen × 6.25 = 1.166 g of apparent protein. Glycine is not protein. A nitrogen test cannot tell the difference.
- 1 gram of creatine monohydrate reads as 1.76 grams of "protein." Creatine monohydrate is 28.17% nitrogen (three nitrogen atoms), so 1 g contributes 0.2817 × 6.25 = 1.761 g of apparent protein, more leverage per gram than any common spiking agent except urea.
- To fake 8.5 g of protein you need only 7.3 g of glycine, or 4.8 g of creatine monohydrate. 8.5 / 1.166 = 7.29 g glycine. 8.5 / 1.761 = 4.83 g creatine monohydrate. 8.5 g is the amount a 2014 class-action complaint against a protein powder maker alleged was spiked into a serving labeled 30 g of protein (21.5 g alleged true whey protein; 8.5 / 30 = 28.3% of the claim).
- Honest ingredients nearly close under amino-acid-sum math; spiked math does not. Summing all 18 amino acids published by USDA FoodData Central for soy protein isolate gives 88.08 g per 100 g against 88.32 g of nitrogen protein, a gap of −0.3%. For wheat flour the gap is 0.0%. The gaps that remain for honest ingredients are small, explainable (see the gelatin finding below), and stable. Added free nitrogen breaks the closure in one direction only: nitrogen protein rises, amino acid sum does not.
- Gelatin is the exception that proves the method needs care: its amino acid sum is 76.53 g against 85.6 g of nitrogen protein, a −10.6% gap, and the gap is a database gap, not spiking. The FoodData Central gelatin entry publishes no hydroxyproline value, and hydroxyproline is a major collagen amino acid. Any audit that flags gelatin on sum math alone, without reading the source entry, is wrong. We flag it here, in our own table, on purpose.
- So what: If your product's nitrogen protein and its amino-acid-sum protein disagree by more than a few percent, in the direction nitrogen > sum, you have either added free nitrogen, a database hole like gelatin's, or a labeling problem. Two tests settle which: a free amino acid profile (AA-1) and a total amino acid profile (AA-T). Total minus free is the protein-bound fraction. Nitrogen alone can never give you that split.
- Why it matters: The 2014 CRN/AHPA voluntary guidance already tells the industry to exclude non-protein nitrogen from protein declarations, retailer verification programs test for exactly this, and protein-spiking litigation shows that an allegation alone is expensive. A $150 free profile plus a $230 total profile ($380 for the pair, $410 for a powder that needs extraction) is the cheapest way to know your own number before a retailer, a plaintiff, or a competitor computes it for you.
Introduction
A protein declaration is usually not measured as protein at all. It is measured as nitrogen and multiplied by 6.25, on the assumption that every nitrogen atom in the sample arrived inside a protein. This article asks how much of the protein printed on a label that assumption can manufacture: how many grams of apparent protein a gram of free glycine, taurine, or creatine adds to a nitrogen result, and how far a finished product can drift from its label before anyone measuring amino acids would notice.
The question matters to anyone who buys, formulates, or sells a protein product, because the gap is not theoretical. It is the mechanism behind protein-spiking litigation, behind retailer verification programs, and behind raw materials that can be priced as protein while delivering mostly cheap free nitrogen. If your product is honest, the same arithmetic is your defense, provided you have run it on your own formulation before someone else does.
Everything here is computed, and every input is named. The exchange rates come from molecular formulas and the nitrogen fraction of each compound. The closure test sums the amino acids published by USDA FoodData Central for honest ingredients and sets that sum against their nitrogen protein. The closing scenario applies the exchange rates to a stated label claim. Read the tables in that order: first what each gram of added nitrogen is worth, then whether honest ingredients close, then what a stated addition does to a real label. The free and total amino acid profiles are the pair of measurements that settle which side of the gap any actual product sits on.
Apparent protein per 1 g added: the spiking exchange rates
Grams of label “protein” a nitrogen test reports for each gram of compound added. True protein, on the 6.25 assumption, would read 1.000.
Table 1: The spiking exchange rates (computed from molecular formulas)
Nitrogen methods (Kjeldahl, Dumas) measure total nitrogen and multiply by 6.25, the factor 21 CFR 101.9(c)(7) permits for protein declaration. Every nitrogen atom counts, wherever it sits.
| Compound | Formula | Molecular weight | Nitrogen % by weight | Apparent "protein" per 1 g added (g) | Grams needed to fake 8.5 g protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Glycine | C2H5NO2 | 75.07 | 18.66 | 1.166 | 7.29 |
| Taurine | C2H7NO3S | 125.15 | 11.19 | 0.700 | 12.15 |
| Creatine (anhydrous) | C4H9N3O2 | 131.13 | 32.05 | 2.003 | 4.24 |
| Creatine monohydrate | C4H9N3O2·H2O | 149.15 | 28.17 | 1.761 | 4.83 |
| Urea (reference, not a food ingredient claim) | CH4N2O | 60.06 | 46.64 | 2.915 | 2.92 |
| True protein (the 6.25 assumption) | n/a | n/a | 16.00 (assumed) | 1.000 | 8.50 |
Worked example. Glycine nitrogen fraction = 14.007 / 75.07 = 0.1866. Apparent protein per gram = 0.1866 × 6.25 = 1.166 g. Grams of glycine to mimic 8.5 g protein = 8.5 / 1.166 = 7.29 g. Creatine monohydrate: nitrogen mass = 3 × 14.007 = 42.021; fraction = 42.021 / 149.15 = 0.2817; × 6.25 = 1.761 g apparent protein per gram; 8.5 / 1.761 = 4.83 g. Every figure in Table 1 re-performs from the formula and standard atomic weight of nitrogen (14.007) alone.
Nitrogen protein vs amino-acid sum: the gap for honest ingredients
Gap as a percent of nitrogen protein, per 100 g (Table 2). Negative means the amino acid sum falls short of the nitrogen figure.
Table 2: Nitrogen protein vs amino-acid-sum protein, honest ingredients (USDA FoodData Central, per 100 g)
| Ingredient (FDC ID, SR Legacy) | Protein as listed in FoodData Central (g) | Sum of 18 published amino acids (g) | Gap (g) | Gap (% of N protein) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Soy protein isolate (174276) | 88.32 | 88.08 | −0.24 | −0.3 |
| Wheat flour, white, all-purpose (169761) | 10.33 | 10.33 | 0.00 | 0.0 |
| Egg, whole, dried (172188) | 48.05 | 48.51 | +0.46 | +1.0 |
| Milk, dry, nonfat (172195) | 36.16 | 37.98 | +1.82 | +5.0 |
| Soy flour, full-fat, raw (174273) | 37.81 | 36.53 | −1.28 | −3.4 |
| Whey, sweet, dried (171283) | 12.93 | 12.33 | −0.60 | −4.6 |
| Peas, green split, raw (172428) | 23.12 | 21.65 | −1.47 | −6.4 |
| Gelatins, dry powder (169599) | 85.60 | 76.53 | −9.07 | −10.6 (see note) |
Worked example. Soy protein isolate: sum = 1.116 (Trp) + 3.137 (Thr) + 4.253 (Ile) + 6.783 (Leu) + 5.327 (Lys) + 1.130 (Met) + 1.046 (Cys) + 4.593 (Phe) + 3.222 (Tyr) + 4.098 (Val) + 6.670 (Arg) + 2.303 (His) + 3.589 (Ala) + 10.203 (Asp) + 17.452 (Glu) + 3.603 (Gly) + 4.960 (Pro) + 4.593 (Ser) = 88.08 g. Gap = 88.08 − 88.32 = −0.24 g; −0.24 / 88.32 = −0.3%.
Basis note. The protein column is the FoodData Central value, which for these entries is computed with food-specific Jones factors, not 6.25 (see the 6.25 problem). The amino acid column is the sum of free-form amino acid masses, which run above the mass the amino acids contribute inside a protein because hydrolysis adds one water molecule per peptide bond. The two differences partly offset, so a closure within a few percent is a screen, not proof.
Reading the signs: a small positive gap (egg, milk) is expected, because FoodData Central amino acids are weighed as free amino acids after hydrolysis, and hydrolysis adds a water molecule across every peptide bond, so the free-amino-acid sum slightly overstates residue mass. A small negative gap reflects amino acids not listed, rounding, and non-amino-acid nitrogen in the food. A large positive nitrogen-minus-sum gap in a finished powder, with no database hole to explain it, is the spiking signature. Gelatin's large gap has a named explanation (no hydroxyproline in the entry) and is therefore a caution about the method, not an accusation.
Table 3: What a stated addition does to a 30 g label claim (computed scenario)
Scenario, stated in full so it can be challenged: a serving contains 21.5 g of true whey protein. Add free compounds. The nitrogen declaration is recomputed from Table 1 exchange rates.
| Addition to the 21.5 g true protein | Apparent protein declared (g) | True protein (g) | Share of declaration that is not protein (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | 21.50 | 21.5 | 0.0 |
| + 7.29 g glycine | 30.00 | 21.5 | 28.3 |
| + 4.83 g creatine monohydrate | 30.00 | 21.5 | 28.3 |
| + 12.15 g taurine | 30.00 | 21.5 | 28.3 |
| + 5.00 g glycine (partial) | 27.33 | 21.5 | 21.3 |
Worked example. 21.5 + (7.29 × 1.166) = 21.5 + 8.50 = 30.00 g declared. Non-protein share = 8.50 / 30.00 = 28.3%. Partial case: 5.00 × 1.166 = 5.83; 21.5 + 5.83 = 27.33 g declared; (27.33 − 21.5) / 27.33 = 21.3% of the declaration is glycine nitrogen wearing a protein label.
This scenario is arithmetic, not a measurement of any product on sale. It is calibrated to the allegation in that 2014 complaint (30 g claimed, 21.5 g alleged whey protein) to show that the alleged gap is achievable with single-digit grams of cheap free compounds. An allegation is not a finding; the complaint is cited for its numbers, not as a verdict.
What the protein number hides: essential amino acids per declared gram
Two products can print the same protein number and deliver very different amounts of the amino acids a buyer wants. Using published ingredient composition (Gorissen et al., 2018) and, for collagen, the typical amino acid profile one maker publishes for its own product, here is the essential amino acid (EAA) share of 1 g of declared protein by archetype. This is label arithmetic on public information, not a measurement of any product.
| Archetype | Declared protein per serving | EAA as % of declared protein | Expected EAA per serving |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whey-blend powder | 24 g | 43% | 10.3 g |
| Milk-protein shake | 26 g | 39% | 10.1 g |
| Plant-blend powder (pea and rice) | 21 g | 28% to 30% | 5.9 to 6.3 g |
| Collagen peptide powder | 18 g | 15.6% | 2.82 g |
Worked example, collagen. The maker's own typical profile sums to 18,000 mg per serving, which closes exactly against the declared 18 g. But the essential amino acids are His 144 + Ile 271 + Leu 524 + Lys 614 + Met 108 + Phe 379 + Thr 343 + Val 433 + Trp 0 = 2,816 mg, or 15.6%. Tryptophan is zero. The 18,000 mg includes hydroxyproline (2,058 mg) and hydroxylysine (217 mg), which are real collagen constituents but are not among the standard amino acids a protein-quality calculation counts; without them the standard-panel sum is 15,725 mg. Glycine, proline and hydroxyproline make up 43.6% of the profile. The 18 g is real amino acid mass, and it is mostly not the essential amino acids.
The whey-blend archetype shows a second effect. A serving of 31 g declaring 24 g of protein, with the whey blend at 93% of the formula, needs the blend to be 24 / 31 / 0.93 = 83.25% protein. Commercial whey measured by Gorissen ran 72% to 84% protein (nitrogen x 6.25), so an isolate-heavy blend reaches that comfortably and a concentrate-heavy blend at 78% would deliver 31 x 0.93 x 0.78 = 22.5 g. Label math flags a question to ask a supplier, never a conclusion about a product. Only laboratory analysis of the actual product clears or convicts it. Note also that the Gorissen amino acid sums are lower bounds, because tryptophan, aspartic acid, asparagine and glutamine were not separately measured.
Sensitivity example, hypothetical. A powder declaring 25 g of protein that contained 5 g of added glycine needs only 25 minus 5.83 = 19.2 g of intact protein to register 25 g by nitrogen, and its leucine, computed at whey's 11.0%, would fall from 2.75 g to 2.11 g. Total amino acids would show the glycine directly, and the free analysis would show it is added, not protein-bound. For brands and buyers the practical steps are the same: self-audit with these computations before a retailer does, keep lot data showing your blend sits where your label needs it, and describe products you discuss by archetype.
Perspectives
Regulatory: permitted method, narrowing guidance
21 CFR 101.9(c)(7) permits protein to be calculated from nitrogen. FDA's position, restated in guidance and warning contexts, is that protein should reflect actual protein. The Council for Responsible Nutrition and AHPA 2014 voluntary guidance tells manufacturers not to count non-protein nitrogen toward protein. The gap between "the method permits it" and "the guidance forbids it" is where litigation lives.
Analytical: why the total-minus-free pair resolves it
Kjeldahl and Dumas return one number: total nitrogen. They are structurally blind to spiking. Amino acid analysis returns two: the free profile before hydrolysis (AA-1) and the total profile after hydrolysis (AA-T). Free glycine and taurine appear in the free run at full strength and add nothing bound; protein-bound amino acids appear only after hydrolysis. Creatine is not an amino acid and is not detected by the AQC method, so a creatine screen needs its own test, CR-1 at $120 per sample. Total minus free, amino acid by amino acid, is the bound protein profile, and its sum is a protein estimate no free addition can inflate.
Commercial: the cost asymmetry
Defending or settling a spiking claim, reformulating under retailer pressure, or losing a listing each cost orders of magnitude more than verification. The verification pair is AA-1 $150 + AA-T $230 = $380 per product, plus $30 per sample if a powder needs extraction (PREP-1), so $410 for a powder. Add CR-1 at $120 if creatine is a suspect. Table 1 is also the procurement warning in reverse: if a protein raw material is priced as if its nitrogen were all protein, you may be buying glycine at whey prices.
Formulator: build a product whose math closes
Declare protein from ingredients whose Table 2 closure you have checked. If you add glycine, taurine, or creatine for a functional reason, disclose them outside the protein line, keep the addition and its nitrogen contribution (Table 1) in the formulation record, and verify the finished product once with the total-minus-free pair. A product whose math closes has nothing to fear from anyone else's arithmetic, including this page's.
Know your own number
A free amino acid profile (AA-1, $150) shows added glycine and taurine at full strength. A total profile (AA-T, $230, hydrolysis included) shows the protein-bound amino acids; it reports 16 amino acids, not tryptophan, and not cysteine unless the AA-3 workup is added. Creatine is not detected by either; test it with CR-1 ($120). Powders that need extraction add PREP-1 at +$30 per sample. We do not offer protein by nitrogen.
The spiking screen is AA-1 plus AA-T on the same product, with CR-1 if creatine is suspected: $380 to $500 per product for a powder that dissolves, and $30 more for each solid needing extraction. Overnight turnaround available, with expedited service on request. Standard results in 3 to 5 business days from receipt.
Order samples See an example report
Methods & Sources
- Gorissen, S.H.M. et al. (2018) "Protein content and amino acid composition of commercially available plant-based protein isolates," Amino Acids 50:1685 to 1695 (PMC6245118): protein contents by Dumas nitrogen x 6.25; whey protein content 72% to 84%, whey EAA 43% of protein, leucine 11.0%; milk EAA 39%; brown-rice EAA 28%.
- USDA FoodData Central, SR Legacy entries (protein and 18 amino acids, per 100 g), via the FoodData Central API: soy protein isolate FDC 174276; wheat flour FDC 169761; egg, whole, dried FDC 172188; milk, dry, nonfat FDC 172195; soy flour FDC 174273; whey, sweet, dried FDC 171283; peas, green split, raw FDC 172428; gelatins, dry powder FDC 169599. https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/, accessed November 5, 2026.
- Molecular weights and formulas: glycine C2H5NO2, 75.07 (USP/FCC specifications); taurine C2H7NO3S, 125.15 (USP specifications); creatine C4H9N3O2, 131.13, monohydrate 149.15; urea CH4N2O, 60.06. Nitrogen atomic weight 14.007. Accessed November 5, 2026.
- 21 CFR 101.9(c)(7): protein declaration by nitrogen × 6.25 (or applicable factor). Accessed November 5, 2026.
- A 2014 US class-action complaint against a protein powder maker alleged 30 g claimed against 21.5 g of whey protein, with glycine, taurine and creatine monohydrate among the alleged spiking agents. Cited for its numbers as an allegation, not as a finding.
- CRN/AHPA 2014 voluntary guidance on protein labeling (exclude non-protein nitrogen), as referenced in the complaint record and industry guidance. Accessed November 5, 2026.
- Limitations: Table 2 sums use only the amino acids FoodData Central publishes for each entry (18, excluding hydroxyproline, which the gelatin entry omits). Finished-product spiking cannot be proven or excluded from database arithmetic; only laboratory analysis of the product itself (total minus free) can do that. Table 3 is a stated scenario, not a product measurement.
Paired reading: Free vs Total Amino Acids: Label Claims per Matrix explains the claim side; this page supplies the computed nitrogen numbers those claims are judged against.