A claim about amino acids that are already free in the product needs a free measurement; a claim about the amino acids bound in a protein needs a total measurement (acid hydrolysis first); a claim about how far a protein has been broken down needs both, because the answer is the difference between them.
The one-sentence rule
A claim about amino acids that are already free in the product needs a free measurement; a claim about the amino acids bound in a protein needs a total measurement (acid hydrolysis first); a claim about how far a protein has been broken down needs both, because the answer is the difference between them.
Ordering the wrong one does not give a weaker answer, it gives an answer to a different question. A free panel on a whey powder reads near zero for most amino acids, not because the powder is empty but because its amino acids are bound. A total panel on a drink spiked with free glycine counts that glycine as if it belonged to the protein.
Companion, not a duplicate: the methods page Free vs Total Amino Acids: Which You Need explains the two preparations in general. This note is the label-claim companion: it works claim by claim, matrix by matrix.
Per matrix: what each claim needs
| Matrix | Typical label claim | Measurement needed | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ready-to-drink beverage / drink mix with free-form amino acids added, no intact protein | "5 g BCAAs per bottle", "EAAs per serving" | Free (AA-1) | The claimed amino acids were added as free amino acids and sit in solution unbound; a free panel measures each one individually, in mg per serving, against the label |
| Beverage or shake with intact protein (dairy, soy, pea) | Grams of protein; amino acid composition; "complete protein" | Total (AA-T) | Nearly all of the amino acids are bound in the intact protein. Only hydrolysis releases them for measurement; a free panel would miss the product itself |
| Supplement powder, intact protein (whey, pea, collagen) | Protein content per scoop; per-amino-acid composition; essential amino acid total | Total (AA-T) | Same reason: the claim is about the protein's composition, which is a bound pool. Report per amino acid in g/100 g and mol%, not as a single nitrogen-derived number |
| Supplement powder or capsules, free-form amino acids (BCAA/EAA blends) | "5 g BCAAs, 2:1:1" per serving | Free (AA-1) | Nothing is bound; there is nothing to hydrolyze. The free panel also verifies the stated ratio, which a total figure alone cannot check (see the BCAA companion note) |
| Protein hydrolysate (powder or drink) | "Hydrolyzed", degree of breakdown, fast-absorption framing | Both (AA-1 + AA-T) | Free shows what has been fully released; total shows the whole composition. The bound share per amino acid is (total − free) ÷ total, neither measurement alone contains it |
| Gummies and chews carrying free-form amino acids | mg of named amino acids per gummy | Free (AA-1), with the prep stated | The claimed amino acids are free-form, but the matrix is not a drink: the sample is dissolved whole before analysis, and the report should say so |
Three traps this prevents
1. The nitrogen shortcut. Grams of protein on a Nutrition Facts panel may be calculated from total nitrogen (nitrogen × 6.25, per 21 CFR 101.9). That is a nitrogen measurement, not an amino acid measurement: cheap free amino acids added to a powder raise the nitrogen number exactly as intact protein does. A per-amino-acid profile, free, total, or the pair, is what separates "protein by arithmetic" from protein by composition.
2. Reading a total number as a free claim (and the reverse). If a drink claims a specific amount of free leucine, a total result cannot support it: the total folds in any leucine still bound in peptides. If a powder claims a full essential-amino-acid composition, a free result cannot support it: most of those amino acids never appear in the free pool. Match the preparation to the claim's own words.
3. Forgetting what hydrolysis changes. A total result is not the free result "plus more of everything". Under the standard conditions (6 N HCl, 110 °C, 24 hours), tryptophan is destroyed and cysteine/cystine is not reported, so AA-T reports 16 amino acids; asparagine and glutamine are converted, so aspartate and glutamate are reported as the combined Asx and Glx; serine and threonine are partly lost, methionine can partly oxidize, and valine and isoleucine bonds hydrolyze slowly, so 24 hours can under-recover them. A label claim that turns on tryptophan, or on glutamine as glutamine, cannot be settled by a total panel at all, it needs the free panel (where both are reported as themselves) or a separate workup. State this before ordering, not after the report lands.
Worked example (illustrative, not laboratory data)
A pea-protein drink mix claims "10 g protein per serving, complete amino acid profile".
- Free panel ordered alone: most amino acids read at trace levels. Wrong conclusion available: "the product is empty". Correct reading: the test skipped the protein.
- Total panel ordered: per-amino-acid composition in g/100 g, Asx/Glx combined, no tryptophan figure. This supports the composition claim for the 16 reported amino acids. Two gaps matter for a pea protein. Tryptophan is destroyed in hydrolysis and is not reported. The sulfur amino acids are usually the limiting group in pea protein, and cysteine is not reported in AA-T while methionine is only partly recovered. The report must flag all three.
- What the brand actually needed: the total panel for composition, plus an explicit plan for the tryptophan and sulfur amino acid gaps, agreed before sampling. Cysteine can be added through an AA-3 workup on request; tryptophan after acid hydrolysis is not offered here.
What to send, and what the report must show
- Name the claim first (for BCAA and drink claims see verifying BCAA label claims and protein drink verification). Send the exact front-panel wording with the sample. The lab's job is to test that sentence, and the free/total choice follows from it.
- Per-amino-acid numbers, not a single total. mg per serving (free claims) or g/100 g and mol% (total composition), each amino acid next to the label figure it is being checked against.
- The preparation, stated. Free: protein removed, no hydrolysis. Total: 6 N HCl, 110 °C, 24 hours, with the hydrolysis artifacts above carried into the report's notes.
- The chromatogram and the run's QC summary, with calibration against reference standards, the evidence behind the numbers, as on every OpenChemWorks report.
Pricing: free amino acids (AA-1, 19 amino acids plus ammonia) $150 per sample; total amino acids (AA-T, hydrolysis included) $230 per sample; free and total on the same sample $380, plus $30 per sample if a powder needs extraction (PREP-1); order minimum $150. See an example report and order samples.
Scope
- This note describes which measurement a claim needs. Results support product and label-claim decisions. Tell us what your results are for and we will confirm the fit before you ship.
- Amino acid analysis does not detect non-amino-acid ingredients (creatine, caffeine and sweeteners each need their own assay), and no amino acid panel by itself establishes a protein-quality score, digestibility is a separate input.
- One sample is one lot at one moment. A label claim is a per-lot promise; the per-lot verification plan in the BCAA companion note applies here unchanged.
- The extended panel compounds are on-request add-ons, not part of the standard panels named above. Taurine is not in the standard 19 amino acid AA-1 panel; AA-1 (Taurine) adds it to the full analysis at $150 per sample.
OpenChemWorks Laboratory · Reviewed by the OpenChemWorks laboratory · Published October 30, 2026 · Updated November 19, 2026